Creamy Homemade Tartar Sauce for Seafood

This simple tartar sauce recipe is incredibly versatile and elevates many dishes beyond the classic fish sandwich or fish sticks. Use it as a creamy spread on burgers or chicken sandwiches, as a dip for fries, roasted or raw vegetables, or as a bright accompaniment to seafood. Once you make this tangy, dill-forward sauce at home, you’ll find yourself reaching for it again and again.

This post may contain affiliate links. See my disclosure policy for details.

In New England, tartar sauce is practically a staple at any fried fish counter—served alongside fried clams, fish cakes, and battered filets. I love it so much I often order extra so every bite of my fish is generously coated in this creamy, bright sauce.

Making tartar sauce at home is straightforward and requires only pantry staples. The homemade version tastes fresher and more vibrant than most store-bought jars, and it’s easy to adjust the components to suit your preferences—more dill, more tang, or a touch of sweetness, depending on what you’re serving it with.

This sauce is surprisingly flexible. It works beautifully with seafood, of course, but it’s also excellent on grilled chicken, as a spread for sandwiches, or as a dipping sauce for fries and roasted vegetables such as cauliflower, asparagus, or zucchini. Try it as an alternative to sour cream on a baked potato for a lemony, herby twist.

Why You’ll Love This Easy Tartar Sauce Recipe

• Quick and simple to prepare with a handful of basic ingredients
• Easy to tailor to your family’s taste—mild, bold, or slightly sweet
• Far more flavorful than most store-bought tartar sauces
• Pairs well with seafood, poultry, burgers, vegetables, and fries

For a classic New England-style fish fry, serve this tartar sauce with crispy fried fish, homemade coleslaw, fries, and warm rolls for a truly comforting meal.

Tartar Sauce Ingredients

You only need a few simple ingredients to make a flavorful tartar sauce:

Mayonnaise – Use your preferred brand or a light mayo if you want fewer calories.

Dill Pickles – Finely diced. You can substitute pickle relish or sweet pickles if you prefer a touch of sweetness.

Fresh Dill – Finely chopped for the best flavor. Freeze-dried dill can be used in the same amount if fresh isn’t available. If you don’t like dill, try chives or parsley instead.

Lemon Juice or Pickle Juice – Use either or a combination for acidity and brightness.

Garlic Powder – If you only have fresh garlic, use about 1 teaspoon of minced garlic as a substitute.

Salt and Freshly Ground Black Pepper – Adjust to taste.

How to Make Tartar Sauce

This tartar sauce comes together in minutes. Combine the ingredients, taste, and chill for best flavor.

Step 1

Place the mayonnaise, diced dill pickles, chopped fresh dill, lemon or pickle juice, garlic powder, salt, and freshly ground black pepper into a bowl.

Step 2

Stir the ingredients together until evenly combined. Taste and adjust seasonings—add more lemon or pickle juice for tang, more mayo to mellow the flavor, or extra pepper for bite.

Step 3

Transfer the sauce to an airtight container, cover, and chill for at least two hours. Chilling allows the flavors to meld and produce a more balanced, rounded sauce.

Make Tartar Sauce in Advance

You can prepare this tartar sauce up to a week ahead and store it in the refrigerator. In fact, the flavor often improves after a day or two as the ingredients have time to marry, making it an ideal make-ahead condiment for gatherings or meal prep.

Substitutions and Variations

Use these ideas to tweak the recipe based on what you like or what you have on hand:

• Stir in a tablespoon of finely chopped red onion or shallot for a sharper bite.
• Use dill pickle relish or sweet relish instead of diced pickles for a different texture and a hint of sweetness.
• Add a splash of Worcestershire sauce for a deeper umami note—especially nice with beef or steak.
• Season with extra black pepper, cayenne, or Old Bay for more heat and complexity.
• Mix in a teaspoon of Dijon mustard or a pinch of mustard powder to complement chicken dishes.
• Swap some or all of the mayonnaise for plain Greek yogurt to lighten the sauce and add tang.
• Use an egg-free or vegan mayonnaise to make the recipe suitable for vegan diets.

Tips & Tricks

• Flavor improves with time—make the sauce several hours ahead for best results.
• Adjust the consistency: thin with lemon or pickle juice, or thicken with more mayonnaise.

What Does Tartar Sauce Go With?

Traditional uses include all types of fried or baked fish and seafood—fish sticks, fried filets, baked cod, crab cakes, and salmon cakes. But this sauce is also excellent on grilled or baked chicken, as a sandwich spread for burgers or chicken sandwiches, and even as a finishing dollop on a warm steak. It’s a superb dip for French fries and pairs nicely with fresh or roasted vegetables like broccoli, asparagus, and cauliflower.

Storage Instructions

Store leftover tartar sauce in a clean, airtight container or a small mason jar in the refrigerator. Keep it on a shelf rather than the refrigerator door for more consistent temperature storage. Properly refrigerated, the sauce will remain good for up to one week.

FAQs